How do you remember chemical reaction reagents, solvents, and products?
1 Answer
I personally don't put forth the effort to memorize them via flash cards, or something of that sort.
Instead, I commit the mechanisms to muscle memory in such a way that I can imagine a reaction mechanism in my head by association with the goal of the reaction itself, and I determine the reactants necessary from there.
So, for example, there are quite a few bromine reactions you may have had to learn:
#"Br"_2,# #"CH"_2"Cl"_2# (bromination of alkene/alkyne)#"Br"_2,# #"H"_2"O"# (intercepted bromination of alkene/alkyne by#"H"_2"O"# )#"HBr"# (hydrobromination)#"HBr",# #"NBS",# #"a peroxide"# (radical hydrobromination on allylic carbon)#"PBr"_3# (#"OH"->"Br"# in alcohols, carboxylic acids, etc)#"Br"_2, "FeBr"_3# (aromatic bromination)#"Br"_2, "PBr"_3, "H"_2"O"# (bromination of alpha-carbon on carboxylic acid; HVZ reaction in acid or base)
...amongst others.
How I reason this out is by branching out from the least complex one and relating them to each other.
-
Bromination is just the basic nucleophilic attack of bromine, forming the cyclopropane analog and then breaking that to give an anti-addition product.
-
Intercepted bromination then, is bromination that goes halfway, and then water intercepts and breaks the ring on the cyclopropane analog before bromine can (because water is a stronger nucleophile), and you still get anti-addition, but
#"OH"# is one of the new substituents instead of#"Br"# . -
Hydrobromination is like a variant where one bromine is instead a hydrogen that adds Markovnikov.
-
Radical hydrobromination builds off of hydrobromination, and instead adds anti-Markovnikov (I associate peroxides with high reactivity and thus radical reactions. Then I say "radical = weird = opposite to expectations" and assert anti-Markovnikov). Not only that, but the bromine adds onto the allylic carbon.
-
I think of using
#\mathbf("PBr"_3)# as in a class of useful reactions that convert alcohols to something more reactive, so you could associate#"PBr"_3# with#"SOCl"_2# , for instance. Grouping usually helps. -
I associate aromatic bromination with the
#"FeBr"_3# being a weird catalyst. When would you ever need to use transition metals to catalyze a normal reaction, right?Think about it---when have you ever needed to know the arrow-pushing mechanism for how a transition metal participates? Those are elusive elements. The only ones you may have used are
#"Cr"# ,#"Mn"# ,#"Ni"# ,#"Pd"# ,#"Cu"# ,#"Fe"# , and#"Zn"# , and my textbook has shown mechanisms involving#"Cr"# (chromic acid oxidation),#"Cu"# (Gilman reagents), and#"Fe"# (aromatic halogenation). The rest were usually said to participate somehow. -
I actually have the hardest time remembering the HVZ reaction, but I do remember that
#"PBr"_3# converts#"OH"# to#"Br"# on alcohols, carboxylic acids, etc., so I associate that with the water in reaction.Reacting water with a carboxylic acid would be pointless if the
#"OH"# on the carboxylic acid was still an#"OH"# ---water has an#"OH"# to contribute too, so it would reform the reactant! So it must have been that the#"OH"# was converted to#"Br"# by#"PBr"_3# . In fact, that is the first step to that reaction!